Green Day
nimrod. (Reprise)
by Marc Hirsh
Green Day
nimrod. (Reprise)
by Marc Hirsh
originally published in Space City Rock, Spring 1999
The success of Dookie will almost certainly be seen as a fluke when the dust settles and industry types and fans alike realize that they may not have been duped but they certainly invested more importance on this band than they ever deserved. Nimrod continues to lower fans' expectations, most likely intentionally. Green Day are starting to take subtle chances, knowing full well that they have nothing to lose, at least nothing they can control. So they go down fighting, which for Green Day means giving you exactly what you want while flipping you off.
There's been a bit of press about the mellowing of Green Day, but frankly, it's misdirected. Sure, the acoustic "Good Riddance" is getting airplay on AAA as well as modern rock radio, but it's no different from Dookie's closing "F.O.D." (except that it doesn't lose its nerve and slam into distortovision halfway through). Petra Haden's violin wouldn't help the excellent Swingers ripoff "Hitchin' A Ride" if the band let her lead instead of fill in the gaps that were already there. Where are the praises of the loopy "King For A Day" (transvestitism set to a dixieland beat) or the instrumental "Last Ride In," a twangy western treat that seems to come from nowhere in these boys' SoCal upbringing?
Still, in the general scheme of Green Day's poppy punk, nothing's really changed overall. Billie Joe still sings from the middle of his throat. The rhythm section is still enormous. The lyrics are still stupid (not Ramones stupid, stupid stupid). "Tre Cool" is still a dumb name. Profanity is still strewn about as a pretension to honesty (tip: next time you hear "Hitchin' A Ride," imagine that Billie Joe is screaming "shock me" right before the solo instead of the profanity that's in the official lyrics and ask yourself which works better). And everybody who's going to buy this album most likely already has it, and thinks it's awesome, and plays it as a sort of badge of honor. And all for the wrong reasons.